Reading Group on Legal, Philosophical, and Historical Foundations of Copyright
As the first phase of the Copyright in Islamic Law Project, the monthly meetings of the Reading Group on Legal, Philosophical, and Historical Foundations of Copyright embarked on a comprehensive exploration of the historical development of copyright law in the Western context, focusing on its legal, philosophical, and historical foundations. The first phase of the group’s investigation involved a meticulous analysis of the evolution of the concept of copyright law in Continental European and Anglo-Saxon legal traditions. By studying landmark cases, legislative acts, and scholarly works, the participants traced the trajectory of copyright law, shedding light on its transformation over time.
Subsequently, the group delved into the theories proposed on copyright law, dedicating their monthly meetings over the course of an academic year to these discussions. The diverse range of theories was scrutinized and debated, offering valuable insights into the underlying principles that shape copyright law. Concepts such as utilitarianism —which centers on the economic and societal benefits derived from copyright protection— were juxtaposed with theories such as the labor theory and personality theory, underscoring the creative effort and moral rights of authors. In the pursuit of a comprehensive understanding, the relationship between copyright law and key concepts such as human rights, public interest, and monopoly rights was thoroughly examined.
The participants engaged in rigorous analysis to explore the intricate balance between protecting authors’ rights and fostering public access to creative works, while also considering the influence of monopolistic practices and the broader societal implications. The culmination of these monthly meetings in December 2022 marked a significant achievement for the reading group. The discussions and debates held throughout the year enhanced the participants’ comprehension of copyright law’s historical development and theoretical foundations. Furthermore, these endeavors laid a solid groundwork for future research projects, aiming to explore copyright law’s role in contemporary society, its adaptability to technological advancements, and its alignment with evolving cultural norms.
